Big Fish, Small pond?...Small Fish, Big Pond?
Posted 15th Nov 2018
Picture the scene: you’re a top performer in your field and you’ve just been offered an ‘amazing’ job at one of the country’s, possibly even world’s, top five companies. The salary is huge and the ‘perks’ fantastic. You’re an expert, now up there with the best of them. You have however also been offered a position with a much smaller firm that’s exciting, dynamic and growing. The salary is quite acceptable and certainly more than you earn now, but the benefits are not the same as those offered by the big company (although you do get a parking space!)...which company do you ultimately accept the offer from?
The top-five company can offer you a range of incredible benefits, millions of pounds invested in research and development, international opportunities, a fantastic name to have on your CV and the chance to work with the best minds in your field…so why wouldn’t you want to be a small fish in a big pond?
The smaller company cannot come close to matching the benefits offered by the big company, their research budget is considerably smaller and the talent you’ll be working with may well not be composed of international influencers, but with your skill, experience and innate talent, you will be a big fish in a small pond.
A study by Canadian researchers sought to find out whether small towns or big cities produced more sports personalities. 2,240 professional athletes were interviewed about their origins and it was discovered that the vast majority came from smaller towns, rather than large cities. In fact 87% of all National Hockey League players in America, for example, came from towns with fewer than 500,000 residents (that may be sizeable for the UK, but it’s small for America!). In the world of American and Canadian sports, you are considerably more likely to succeed as a big fish in a small pond, than you are being a small fish in the vast pond of a big city.
Research by Gong, Sun, and Wei in 2017 examined the effect of relegation on football players, where their team had been demoted from the Premier League to the First Division. Although clubs that had been demoted often then lost their most prized players, the remaining squad found they had, on average, an additional 12% more time of play, allowing the remaining team to improve - they had become the big fish in the little, or littler, pond. Rather than remaining on the bench (as they had often been in the Premier League) the players were playing more, which had the benefit of improving their game and long-term career prospects as footballers.
The offer of a dream job in a dream company may not be the dream you expect it to be. Being a smaller fish in a bigger pond can often mean being drowned out in the noise of all the other smaller fish. The benefits may be fantastic, but will being a small fish there help your career? In a big pond would you find yourself sitting on the bench at times? By contrast, the smaller pond may well afford you many more opportunities to demonstrate your skill and shine. Will you feel more satisfied working for one company than the other? Are you after a brand name for your CV or the next move in a career you have dedicated your life to developing?
Big ponds are fantastic places to be if you need the resources or want the ‘perks’ that a big company can very often bring, but smaller ponds perhaps allow you to be noticed, for your voice to be heard, and for your skill and experience to matter more. Are you better off as a small fish in a big pond or a big fish in a small pond?
Recent blogs
-
My Generation…
24th Nov 2023
-
Retention is The New Recruitment…and Recruitment...
19th Oct 2023
-
A ‘Crystal Ball’ for Hiring and Retaining
20th Sep 2023
-
Why Subjective Employee Hiring Decisions Are...
5th Sep 2023
-
The Limitations of ‘Traditional’ Hiring...
21st Aug 2023
-
Best Practices for Interviewing Accounting...
18th Jul 2023
-
Interview Tips for Hiring the Best Marketing...
18th Jul 2023
-
Some Interesting Labour Market Data and How to...
5th May 2023
-
What Your Future Employees are Really Looking for...
9th Mar 2022
-
What job seekers are looking for as we move into...
23rd Nov 2021
-
Some thoughts, and facts, on the current labour...
15th Sep 2021
-
Increase Success at Securing Your Candidate of...
25th Jun 2021
-
Video Interviewing…it is here…and it is here...
18th May 2021
-
10 Great Questions to Ask When Next Interviewing a...
23rd Apr 2021
-
10 Great Questions to Ask When Next Interviewing a...
22nd Apr 2021
-
Marketing Considerations in 2021
31st Mar 2021
-
5 Challenges Faced by HR Managers In 2021
31st Mar 2021
-
10 Great Questions to Ask When Next Interviewing a...
25th Mar 2021
-
5 Challenges Faced by Finance Managers In 2021
19th Mar 2021
-
2021 - A Year of Two Halves
25th Feb 2021
-
A Look at The Labour Market
29th Jan 2021
-
Some positives from 2020…and many more to look...
18th Dec 2020
-
There’s still room for...
24th Nov 2020
-
8 Great Interview Questions…
14th Oct 2020
-
Does the increase in ‘working from...
16th Sep 2020
-
Working with a pandemic: video based communication...
17th Jul 2020
-
The Pandemic and Remote Working
20th Mar 2020
-
There’s Still Room For Tradition In Recruitment
4th Oct 2018
-
The Autumn Bank Holiday and Beyond Sporting...
22nd Aug 2018
-
AI and the Future - Where Are We Heading?
27th Jun 2018
-
How to Embrace Artificial Intelligence in Your...
30th May 2018
-
The Rise of Artificial Intelligence in Accounting...
17th Apr 2018
-
AI in Sales - the What, How and When - and is your...
20th Mar 2018
-
The Fourth Industrial Revolution: who will rule...
6th Feb 2018
-
Why The Christmas Holiday is a Good Time to Hire
27th Dec 2017
-
The World’s Weirdest Interviews
16th Nov 2017
-
Perfecting the Recruitment Process
28th Sep 2017
-
Ten Jobs You Wouldn’t Believe Exist
25th Aug 2017
-
Some Good News!
27th Jul 2017
-
The Top Five Cities in the UK for Employment in...
31st May 2017
-
Is Remote Working Really The future? (or: how...
9th May 2017
-
The Importance of Marketing Your Business
7th Mar 2017
-
5 Trends in Accounting for 2017
31st Jan 2017
-
Why Brexit Ruined Christmas
6th Dec 2016
-
The Best of the Rest: What to Expect from the Last...
13th Sep 2016
-
Brexit and the UK Job Market
4th Aug 2016
-
The Olympics - Looking Back to Look Forward
11th Jul 2016
-
Good Communication Changes Everything
7th Jun 2016
-
Blusterous Blunders
13th Apr 2016
-
Travel and Subsistence - All Change for...
26th Feb 2016
-
What Can You Expect From 2016?
25th Jan 2016
-
Ten of The Best in 2015
21st Dec 2015
-
Recruiters or Robots?
23rd Nov 2015
-
Britain and China - The New Special Relationship?
27th Oct 2015
-
Why Shopping for Christmas Cards in September is a...
24th Sep 2015
-
Home vs Office: where’s best to work?
21st Aug 2015
-
The Top Five Tips to Conquer Office Politics
1st Jul 2015
-
What The Conservatives Will Do For Contractors
18th May 2015
-
Now is The Time of The IT Contractor
20th Apr 2015
-
The Top Five Apps for Accountants
10th Mar 2015
-
Why The World Would End Without Contractors
21st Jan 2015
-
Santa Calls for Help
15th Dec 2014
-
6 Stories About Contractors That Will Make Your...
10th Dec 2014
-
Are Tattoos Acceptable in The Modern Workplace?
17th Nov 2014
-
Interims Can Often Be Your Best Option
7th Oct 2014
-
Different Flavours
25th Sep 2014
-
Recruitment Days Gone By
19th Aug 2014
-
Recruitment Trends 2014
24th Jul 2014
-
Candidates Matter
7th Jul 2014
-
Let’s Work Together
19th Jun 2014